Research Status · v2.0.0 · Reference Implementation

Dashboard

Research status and scientific maturity

A reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the falsification-first governance architecture specified in v0.1.0. 15 modules, 60 tests, 3 experiments. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument; F5 is untested.

15
Python Modules
60
Tests Passing
3
Experiments
5
Failure Conditions

Foundational Documents

DocumentVersionStatus
01 — Orchestrate Study0.1.0Complete
02 — Govern Study0.1.0In progress
03 — Runtime Study0.1.0Pending
04 — Comparison0.1.0Pending
Research Paper (PDF)0.1.0Published (Zenodo)
OSF Registration0.1.0Published (OSF)
Reference Implementation2.0.0✅ Built (15 modules)
Test Suite2.0.0✅ 60 tests passing
Experiments (M1–M5)2.0.0✅ 3/3 completed
PyPI Package2.0.0⏳ Publishing

Scientific Maturity

IndicatorStatusNotes
Research problemSpecifiedGovernance gap in the Aether family
Central questionSpecifiedIs governance a genuine gap?
Formal definitionsDefined4 definitions (as layers)
PropositionsStated2 propositions (proof sketches)
Failure conditionsStated5 (F1–F5)
RequirementsStated6 (R1–R6)
Implementation✅ Built15 modules in src/aethergovern/
Tests✅ 60 passed7 test files
Experiments✅ 3/3 completedM1–M5 (simulated data)
PyPI package⏳ Publishingaethergovern 2.0.0
Real-world deploymentNot evaluatedNo deployment
Causal claimsNoneArgument only

Publication Status

VenueStatus
Zenodo (v0.1.0)10.5281/zenodo.24054524
Concept DOI10.5281/zenodo.24054523
OSF10.17605/OSF.IO/TAHC8
OSF Projectosf.io/we2tm
PyPIpypi.org/project/aethergovern (publishing)
GitHubgithub.com/gitdeeper15/aethergovern
GitLabgitlab.com/gitdeeper15/aethergovern
Codebergcodeberg.org/gitdeeper15/aethergovern
Bitbucketbitbucket.org/gitdeeper15/aethergovern
Netlifyaethergovern.netlify.app

Structural Counts

CategoryCount
Formal Definitions4
Propositions2
Failure Conditions5 (F1–F5)
Requirements6 (R1–R6)
Governance Layers5
Figures5
References25
Open Questions20 (Q1–Q20)
Design Principles8 (P1–P8)
Threats to Validity7
Python Modules15
Tests60 (all passing)
Experiments3

Failure Conditions F1–F5

IDClaim under testStatus
F1Non-redundancy🟡 Not falsified (R1, R3, R5)
F2Orthogonality to verification🟡 Not falsified (narrowly)
F3Boundary with orchestration🟡 Not falsified (decentralized setting)
F4Decentralizability🟡 Not falsified (with residuals)
F5Observable benefit🔴 Untested
"Not falsified" is a weaker status than "confirmed". F5 (observable benefit) is untested. The paper does not promote "not falsified" to "confirmed".

Propositions

#PropositionStatus
P1Determinism of Causal-Authority AdmissionProof sketch · implemented in code
P2Monotonicity of RevocationProof sketch · implemented in code
Both propositions are stated with proof sketches; neither is machine-checked. They bear on F4 (decentralizability).

Evaluation Design (Proposed)

#MetricDirection
M1Unauthorized-action admission rateLower is better
M2Exposure countLower is better
M3Exposure durationLower is better
M4Attribution completenessHigher is better
M5Attribution accuracyHigher is better
M6False-rejection rateLower is better
M7Dispute handlingLower is better (time)
M8Admission overheadLower is better
M9Convergence preservationMust be zero
In the v0.1.0 paper, no evaluation was performed. The v2.0.0 experiments cover M1–M5 in simulation only. M6–M9 remain untested.
Status note (v2.0.0): This is a reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the falsification-first governance architecture specified in v0.1.0. 15 modules, 60 tests, 3 experiments. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument, with residual weaknesses. F5 (observable benefit) is untested. Propositions P1–P2 remain proof sketches (not machine-checked). The final project structure (single, dual, or triple project) is undetermined. The paper is not peer reviewed.